''trotsky was like a general who didn't know what he should do unless there was a war on somewhere his big moment was the revolution, and he wanted to spread revolution all over the world we. Trotsky was the odd deposed african dictator - once deposed they are bound to ponder about the significance of democracy (see degenerate workers state theory) whilst in power they just do what the governing clique expects of them and what the office obliges them to do. How far do you agree that women had made significant gains in their fight for equality by 1980 equality is ensuring individuals or groups of individuals are treated fairly and equally on the grounds of their race, gender, religion, disability, age or sexual orientation. How far do you agree that trotsky’s leadership of the red army was responsible for the survival of the bolshevik government in october 1917 the bolshevik’s took control of russia after staging a revolution.
The bolsheviks, on the other hand, had control of the main cities of moscow and petrograd (with their factories), control of the railways (vital), an army of 300,000 men, very strict army discipline, and internal lines of communication – giving them the advantage in the war. Trotsky would be held as a prisoner of war for a month in nova scotia eventually he was released it wasn’t long before trotsky was back in russia, playing a leading role in the october revolution. Exiled russian revolutionary leon trotsky is fatally wounded by an ice-ax-wielding assassin at his compound outside mexico city the killer–ramón mercader–was a spanish communist and probable.
Do you agree that trotsky was the strongest candidate to run the communist party after the death of lenin when lenin died, there was 5 main contenders to take over the reins these five contenders were trotsky, stalin, bukharin, kamenev and zinoviev. How far do you agree that the weaknesses and mistakes of stalin’s rivals was the main factor allowing stalin to rise to power throughout the summer of 1923, lenin lay close to death, and a lull settled over the political struggle. How far do you agree with this statement 8 do you think your society will benefit from having more freedom 9 “fine in principle but a failure in practice” the following essay questions are adapted from “ks bull 2011 issue 2”: “the government always acts in the interest of the people” discuss. Trotsky, leonpermanent revolution critique of soviet bureaucracy other contributions works by trotsky supplementary bibliography leon trotsky  (lev davidovich bronstein) was born in the ukraine in 1879 and assassinated in mexico in 1940.
“trotsky’s mistakes were the main reason that stalin came to power” how far do you agree with this statement (24 marks) there is an ongoing debate between historians as to whether stalin’s rise to power was a result of trotsky’s mistakes or other factors such as stalin’s individual successes and/or individual genius. You need to answer the question directly and this means that you need to say how much you agree or disagree with the idea it is not really enough to say “i agree” or “i disagree” if you do that you haven’t answered the question fully. How far do you agree that the limited appeal of mazzini’s ideas was the main reason for the slow progress of national unity in italy in the years 1815-48 in 1815, italy had just emerged from napoleonic rule and was completely divided into nine separate states with different rulers and different cultures. - why did stalin rather then trotsky emerge as leader of the ussr essay introduction (12 marks) a power struggle for control of the bolsheviks party began after lenin’s death in 1924 (12 marks) a power struggle for control of the bolsheviks party began after lenin’s death in 1924.
Home a level and ib history how far do you agree that trotsky's leadership of the red army was the most important reason for bolshevik successes in russia after the period october/ november 1917-24. Health is 100% the responsibility of the individual, and if the state is interested in the performance and effectiveness of its people, it behoves the state to make healthcare available for its citizens in an affordable, accessible way for exampl. How far do you agree that trotsky’s leadership of red army was responsible for survival of the bolshevik government the bolsheviks had some control of russia, when tsar had been abdicated and when the provisional government was in charge for a short period. Uncovering the truth about trotsky and the russian revolution “continues to run my life” a conversation with the remarkable david king by david walsh.
The phrasing “do you agree or disagree” implies you are to make a simple assessment whereas “to what extent do you agree or disagree” is asking for a deeper analysis of how much you agree or disagree. Read this essay on how far do you agree that the main reason for the fall of the provisional government was the skill and determination of lenin in 1917 come browse our large digital warehouse of free sample essays get the knowledge you need in order to pass your classes and more only at termpaperwarehousecom.
Leon trotsky the following day soviet newspapers carried the announcement that all sixteen defendants had been put to death this included the nkvd agents who had provided false confessions. Start studying gcse history - 'there was little progress in medicine in britain during the renaissance period' how far do you agree learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. The personality and the writings of leon trotsky have long been a rallying point for anticommunists throughout the world but during the 1930s trotsky deliberately lied in his writings about joseph stalin and the soviet union. The bolsheviks in power when the bolsheviks seized power in petrograd in november 1917, they faced many problems not least was the fact that the bolsheviks only controlled a very small part of russia – basically the land between petrograd and moscow, a rectangular band of territory 30 miles by 400 miles.